AI-made festive advertising is prompting a question beyond whether the pictures look convincing: what creative work do viewers believe they are seeing? The Conversation argues that discovering an advert used AI can change how audiences value its craft, even when the finished film looks polished.
Watch Desk analysis
What happened
In an article published on 18 November, The Conversation points to brands including Very and Plusnet using AI in Christmas adverts, and to the backlash over Coca-Cola’s 2025 campaign. It also offers a useful counterexample: viewers suspected AI in Dior’s Christmas film, but director Sylvain Chomet and producer Aton Soumache said it was hand-drawn. They acknowledged using automated interpolation for a small, repetitive part of the animation, which the article distinguishes from generative AI.
The piece argues that viewers care about the process behind an image, not only the image itself. Its examples also show why suspicion is not proof: a strange-looking detail can prompt accusations of AI even when the creators say that is not how the work was made. Read The Conversation’s article.
Why it matters
For brands, the practical question is whether to disclose AI use and explain where it fits in the production. The article argues that audiences may judge work differently when they believe it was presented as human-made, while Dior’s case shows that viewers can also misidentify conventional animation techniques as AI.
That leaves companies with more than a labelling problem. Showing the people and process behind a campaign may help audiences understand what was made, and how. But a behind-the-scenes account is only useful if it is clear about the technology involved.
Our read
The article makes a persuasive case that creative labour is part of what an advert asks us to appreciate. Still, “looks like AI” is not a reliable verdict, and disclosure should clarify the process rather than become another badge on the tin. The useful standard is candour: say what tools were used and what people contributed.
What to watch
- Whether brands explain AI use in the advert itself or only in separate announcements.
- Whether behind-the-scenes material makes the human and automated parts of production clear.
- Whether audience suspicion increasingly treats visual quirks as proof of AI use.
Discussion spark: Should brands be expected to disclose AI use in an advert itself, or is a clear account of the production process elsewhere enough?
Sources and evidence
- The philosophical reason AI Christmas ads leave audiences feeling cold – The Conversation (18 November 2026, 16:02 UTC)
Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.