A Tutorela founder argues that AI can explain the maths but cannot, on its own, persuade pupils to keep practising. He points to his company’s experience and a study of Khan Academy’s AI tutor to make the case for putting teachers and tutors in charge, with AI helping between lessons.
Watch Desk analysis
What happened
Writing in Fortune on 18 November, Roee Naim says only about 10% of students used Tutorela’s AI-assisted maths app, and most did not stick with it. When tutors assigned and followed up on practice using the same app, he says, more than half of those students completed their assignments.
Naim also cites a two-year randomised trial in 18 Tennessee middle schools. According to his account, students used Khanmigo intermittently, and their maths gains matched those from Khan Academy practice without AI. He says Khan Academy reports that about 15% of students with access to Khanmigo engage with it.
Why it matters
The argument is not that AI tutors cannot explain a tricky step. Naim says they can offer help between lessons, at any hour, and provide practice at a scale a person could not mark alone. His point is that access to good explanations does not guarantee students will use them: a tutor, teacher or parent can set goals and follow up.
That distinction matters to schools weighing AI-heavy teaching models. A polished tool may still need a person to make sure the work gets done. The figures here come from Naim’s account and a study he cites, not a verdict on every AI tutoring product or classroom.
Our read
This is a useful challenge to the idea that better software automatically means better learning. The strongest detail is the comparison Naim describes: the app stayed the same, while a tutor’s assignments and follow-up changed how many students completed their work. AI may be a capable teaching aid; accountability is a different job, and it still has a human face.
What to watch
- Whether the Tennessee trial’s published findings support the figures and interpretation Naim gives.
- Whether schools using AI tutors build in meaningful teacher or tutor follow-up.
- Whether future studies find similar engagement patterns across different tools and age groups.
Discussion spark: Should schools treat human follow-up as an essential part of AI tutoring, or should an AI tool be expected to earn regular use on its own?
Sources and evidence
- Source update (18 November 2026, 12:30 UTC)
Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.